INTERNACIONAL
South Africa’s genocide case against Israel sets up a high-stakes legal battle at the UN’s top court
THE HAGUE, Netherlands (AP) — South Africa has launched a case at the United Nations’ top court alleging that Israel’s military campaign in Gaza amounts to genocide.
The filing and Israel’s decision to defend itself at the International Court of Justice set up a high-stakes showdown before a panel of judges in the Great Hall of Justice.
OVER 2,000 SOUTH AFRICAN MINERS REMAIN UNDERGROUND AS UNION PROTEST ENTERS SECOND DAY
The case will likely drag on for years. At its heart is the 1948 Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide, drawn up in the aftermath of World War II and the Holocaust.
The convention defines genocide as acts such as killings «committed with intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnical, racial or religious group.»
Here are some further details on the case and its ramifications.
WHAT IS SOUTH AFRICA’S ARGUMENT?
South Africa’s 84-page filing says Israel’s actions «are genocidal in character because they are intended to bring about the destruction of a substantial part» of the Palestinians in Gaza.
It asks the ICJ, also known as the world court, for a series of legally binding rulings. It wants the court to declare that Israel «has breached and continues to breach its obligations under the Genocide Convention,» and to order Israel to cease hostilities in Gaza that could amount to breaches of the convention, to offer reparations, and to provide for reconstruction of what it’s destroyed in Gaza.
The filing argues that genocidal acts include killing Palestinians, causing serious mental and bodily harm, and deliberately inflicting conditions meant to «bring about their physical destruction as a group.» And it says statements by Israeli officials express genocidal intent.
South Africa argues that the court has jurisdiction because both countries are signatories of the genocide convention. The convention’s ninth article says disputes between nations over the convention can be submitted to the International Court of Justice.
Many South Africans, including President Cyril Ramaphosa, have compared Israel’s policies regarding Palestinians in Gaza and the West Bank with South Africa’s past apartheid regime of racial segregation. Israel rejects such allegations.
WHAT WAS ISRAEL’S RESPONSE?
Israel’s government swiftly rejected the genocide claim. A Foreign Ministry statement said South Africa’s case lacks a legal foundation and constitutes a «despicable and contemptuous exploitation» of the court.
Eylon Levy, an official in the Israeli prime minister’s office, on Tuesday accused South Africa of «giving political and legal cover» to the Oct. 7 attack by Hamas that triggered Israel’s campaign. But he confirmed that Israel would send a legal team to the Hague «to dispel South Africa’s absurd blood libel,» he said.
An Israeli official said the country, which has a history of ignoring international tribunals, decided to defend itself for several reasons. Among them are Israel’s role in promoting the original genocide convention after the Holocaust and its belief that «we have a strong case.» He spoke on condition of anonymity because he was discussing behind-the-scenes deliberations.
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has vowed to press ahead with the war until Hamas is crushed and the more than 100 hostages still held by the militant group in Gaza are freed. He’s said that could take several more months.
WHAT HAPPENS NEXT?
South Africa’s filing includes a request for the court to urgently issue legally binding interim orders for Israel to «immediately suspend its military operations in and against Gaza.»
Such orders, known as provisional measures, would remain while the case progresses. They’re legally binding but not always followed. In 2022, in a genocide case filed by Ukraine against Russia, the court ordered Moscow to immediately suspend its invasion. The order was ignored, and deadly strikes continue.
The court will soon schedule public hearings. Lawyers for South Africa and Israel can make arguments. Judges drawn from around the world will likely take days or weeks to issue a decision on preliminary measures.
The court will then enter a lengthy process of considering the full case.
Israel could challenge the jurisdiction and seek to have the case thrown out before lawyers start arguing. Other countries that have signed the genocide convention could also apply to make submissions.
IS THE COURT HEARING SIMILAR CASES?
Two other genocide cases are on the busy court’s docket. The case filed by Ukraine shortly after Russia’s invasion accuses Moscow of launching the military operation based on trumped-up claims of genocide and accuses Russia of planning acts of genocide in Ukraine.
Another ongoing case involves Gambia — acting on behalf of Muslim nations — accusing Myanmar of genocide against the Rohingya Muslim minority.
In a past case brought by Bosnia, the court in 2007 ruled that Serbia «violated the obligation to prevent genocide … in respect of the genocide that occurred in Srebrenica in July 1995.» The court declined to order Serbia to pay compensation. Croatia also sued Serbia in 2015, but the world court ruled that Serbia didn’t breach the convention in that case.
ICJ OR ICC?
The Hague calls itself the international city of peace and justice. It is home not only to the ICJ, but to the International Criminal Court, based just a few miles (kilometers) away, near the North Sea coastline.
The two courts have different mandates.
The ICJ, which held its first sitting in 1946 as the world emerged from the carnage of WWII, adjudicates cases between nations. They’re often land and maritime border disputes, as well as disagreements over interpretation of international treaties.
The ICC is much younger. It started work in 2002 with the lofty goal of ending global impunity for atrocities. Unlike the ICJ, it seeks to hold individuals criminally responsible for genocide, war crimes and crimes against humanity.
The ICC has an ongoing investigation into the Israel-Palestinian conflict, dating back to the last war in Gaza. So far, it has not issued any arrest warrants.
ICC prosecutor Karim Khan said last month that an investigation into possible crimes by Hamas militants and Israeli forces «is a priority for my office.»
WHAT ABOUT PAST U.N. CASES?
Two now-defunct U.N. tribunals also held landmark genocide trials.
The International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia convicted a series of high-ranking Bosnian Serbs, including former President Radovan Karadzic and his military chief Gen. Ratko Mladic, for their roles in the July 1995 massacre of more than 8,000 men and boys in the Bosnian town of Srebrenica.
CLICK HERE TO GET THE FOX NEWS APP
Both Karadzic and Mladic were given life sentences.
The International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda convicted a string of leaders involved in the African nation’s 1994 genocide when some 800,000 people, mainly ethnic Tutsis, were slaughtered.
U.S. envoy to the Middle East Steve Witkoff is heading to Russia later this week, a source familiar with the matter told Fox News.
The confirmation comes after media reports said Witkoff is planning to meet with Russian President Vladimir Putin for a second time.
Witkoff previously met Putin for three hours in mid-February during a trip to Moscow to secure the release of detained American Marc Fogel, according to Axios.
The Kremlin then suggested around that time that another U.S.-Russia prisoner swap could be coming.
UKRAINE LAUNCHES BIGGEST DRONE ATTACK ON MOSCOW, KILLING 2, AS US TALKS BEGIN
Steve Witkoff, White House special envoy for the Middle East, center, accompanied by White House press secretary Karoline Leavitt, speaks with reporters at the White House in Washington on Thursday, March 6. (AP/Ben Curtis)
Witkoff, Secretary of State Marco Rubio and National Security Advisor Mike Waltz are currently in Saudi Arabia meeting a senior Ukrainian delegation for talks about ending the Ukraine-Russia war.
The Ukrainian delegation in Saudi Arabia was expected to include Andriy Yermak, head of the presidential office, Andrii Sybiha, minister of foreign affairs, Pavlo Palisa, colonel of armed forces of Ukraine and an advisor to Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy, as well as Defense Minister Rustem Umerov, who was not only involved in initial talks with Russia following its February 2022 invasion, but who also survived a poisoning attack after a peace meeting in March that year.
HAMAS’ TREATMENT OF HOSTAGES ‘INTOLERABLE,’ TRUMP ENVOY SAYS
President Donald Trump greets former detainee Marc Fogel as he arrives at the White House in Washington, D.C., on Feb. 11. (Ting Shen/AFP via Getty Images)
Rubio told reporters Monday that «The important point in this meeting is to establish clearly their intentions, their desire, as they’ve said publicly now, numerous times, to reach a point where peace is possible,» adding that he will need to be assured that Kyiv is prepared to make some hard decisions, like giving up territory seized by Russia, in order to end the three-year war.
Steve Witkoff, US special envoy to the Middle East, during an executive order signing ceremony in the Oval Office of the White House in Washington, DC, US, on Monday, Feb. 3. (Chris Kleponis/CNP/Bloomberg via Getty Images)
CLICK HERE TO GET THE FOX NEWS APP
«I wouldn’t prejudge tomorrow about whether or not we have a minerals deal,» Rubio also said on board a flight to Saudi Arabia. «It’s an important topic, but it’s not the main topic on the agenda.
Fox News’ Caitlin McFall contributed to this report.
INTERNACIONAL
Donald Trump sube al 50% los aranceles previstos para el acero y el aluminio de Canadá y escala la guerra comercial con su vecino
Anexar Canadá
Los mercados reciben mal las políticas arancelarias de Trump. Foto: ReutersINTERNACIONAL
Con tono «constructivo», Estados Unidos y Ucrania ya negocian para poner fin a la guerra: en la mesa, un crítico acuerdo por minerales y una tregua por aire y mar
Conversaciones en el Ritz Carlton
La delegación ucraniana llega a la cita. Foto: EFE¿Vuelve la ayuda de inteligencia a Ucrania?
El ataque ucraniano a Moscú
La reacción rusa
Moscú reivindica un gran avance en la región de Kursk
Más allá del “triángulo de hierro”: La Libertad Avanza gana bancas en el sector editorial
La otra cara de la Fiesta de la Vendimia: Mitines políticos, explotación y abandono del estado
Buena noticia para Scaloni y la Selección: Dibu Martínez se entrenó con normalidad en el Aston Villa
Revelan cuánto tardarían en reducir la pobreza del mundo a la mitad
Luciano Vietto de pensar en el retiro al mejor momento de su carrera: “Estoy en el momento más feliz”
Trump envoy Witkoff heading to Russia for second time later this week, source says
Elisa Carrió anunció que será candidata a diputada en las próximas elecciones legislativas
Tormenta en Bahía Blanca: la ciudad quedó bajo el agua por la lluvia y varias familias fueron evacuadas
Los datos de la indigencia en CABA: en dos años aumentaron un 55% las personas en situación de calle
Documentos oficiales: la Argentina enfrenta 236 demandas fuera del país por más de US$27.000 millones
El Gobierno está decidido a cerrar el acuerdo con el FMI en las próximas semanas y se hará oficial en esta fecha
Vecinos de barrios porteños cortaron la calle en reclamo por los cortes de luz: “Ya son cinco días”
Luciano Vietto de pensar en el retiro al mejor momento de su carrera: “Estoy en el momento más feliz”
El delantero de la Academia contó intimidades de su paso por Arabia Saudita y como cambió su vida en su...
VIDEO | Manu Ginóbili se sumó a la campaña solidaria por Bahía Blanca: “Tenemos que ayudar”
El exbasquetbolista habló de la tragedia que azotó a su ciudad natal y dio detalles de cómo colaborar con los...
A pesar de las críticas de la oposición, Javier Milei firmó el DNU del acuerdo con el FMI
El nuevo programa aún debe ser tratado por el directorio del Fondo y el Congreso incluso podría rechazar el decreto...
-
POLITICA2 días agoDocumentos oficiales: la Argentina enfrenta 236 demandas fuera del país por más de US$27.000 millones
-
POLITICA2 días ago
El número de muertos por las inundaciones en Bahía Blanca subió a 15
-
POLITICA2 días ago
El Gobierno acusó al kirchnerismo de agitar los reclamos sociales para desestabilizar
